Print

HMRC's personal tax contentious issues panel has conceded that in certain cases it will allow taxpayers' claims for Mansworth v Jelly loss relief. This will bring to an end many long running disputes over share losses.

Background

Following litigation, HMRC's advice in January 2003 was that Mansworth v Jelly capital losses were allowable. 
The law in relation to unapproved share options changed in April 2003, and so for disposals of shares acquired under option schemes after that date there were no losses.

The position for taxpayers with these type of losses is as follows:

1. If the loss has never been claimed against capital gains there is now no hope of making a claim going forward.
2. If the loss has been offset in an earlier tax return and HMRC did not open an enquiry within the set time limits required there is nothing HMRC can do to claw back relief. The return enquiry window is now closed. So these taxpayers have the benefit of the loss.
3. If a taxpayer has claimed a loss against capital gains before HMRC changed its guidance, but HMRC opened an enquiry into the tax return and so did not agree the loss, and has still not agreed the loss, following HMRC new concession the taxpayer may now be able to make a claim on the basis that he had a legitimate expectation that HMRC's guidance at the time of making the return was correct.

Current position

Claims for loss relief are now being allowed if the taxpayer:

Cases

In The Queen on the application of Ralph Hely-Hutchinson v HMRC [2015] a taxpayer was successful in judicial review over HMRC's tax treatment of his Mansworth v Jelly loss claims, however the decision of the FTT was overturned by the Court of Appeal in R (Hely-Hutchinson) v HMRC [2017] EWCA Civ 1075 . The technical point regarding the availability of the losses claimed has been remitted back to the First-tier Tribunal to decide. It remains to be seen whether there will be any further appeal in this case.

Update

16/08/17 -  Court of appeal decision in R v Hely-Hutchinson added.