HMRC have published their response to the consultation, 'Modernising and standardising company tax returns'. Mandatory online filing of amended Company Tax Returns will apply from 1 April 2028, with further consultation and testing to be undertaken before introducing the prescription of Corporation Tax computations. 

Calculator

The Consultation, which ran from 10 March to 2 June 2026, sought feedback on implementation timelines for the prescription of Corporation Tax computations, arrangements to ensure a smooth transition to the new rules, and proposals for proportionate enforcement mechanisms to ensure compliance. 

  • The prescription of Corporation Tax computations means requiring companies to prepare and submit their tax computations in a standardised, fully tagged format, rather than allowing them to use their own formats.

It also considered the introduction of mandatory online filing for company tax return amendments and invited opinions on any potential issues. 

  • It included a proposed timetable for prescribed computations, envisioning a live pilot period between October 2027 and September 2028.
  • It proposed options for enforcement measures to apply to software developers who persist with non-compliance and to protect those who do meet the required standards.  
  • It asked whether mandatory online filing for Corporation Tax return amendments should begin later than April 2027 and whether exemptions should apply.

Outcome of the consultation

 At Budget 2026, following the consultation, the government announced that:

  • Mandatory online filing will apply to tax return amendments submitted on or after April 2028 regardless of the accounting period to which they relate.
  • Further consultation and testing will be undertaken before introducing the prescription of Corporation Tax computations that will now take place under a longer and more flexible timeline. 
  • Enforcement measures applying directly to Corporation Tax software providers will not be introduced at this time.

HMRC received 40 responses to the consultation from representative bodies, advisory firms, software providers, and businesses and also met extensively with stakeholders throughout the consultation period.

Prescribed computations

  • Respondents broadly supported the objective of greater consistency and standardisation within Corporation Tax returns, recognising the benefits of improving data quality to support HMRC’s compliance and customer service functions.
    • However, they considered the proposed timelines challenging, citing the scale and complexity of the changes, the need for further testing (in particular that the software works effectively with existing systems and processes), the need to train end users, and the importance of minimising additional burdens on taxpayers, agents and software providers.
    • Most respondents did not consider a 12‑month pilot phase sufficient to identify and resolve implementation issues, particularly for more complex areas of the return.
    • Concerns were also raised over having time to properly consider specific issues such as views from in-house tax teams, complex areas (e.g. loan relationships), sector-specific sections (e.g insurance) and overlaps with broader information requirements on corporates.

As a result, the government has paused its co-creation process and revisited the proposed implementation timeline for prescribed computations.

  • Further consultation will take place in 2027 alongside testing and refining the draft prescribed requirements before they are finalised over a longer, more flexible timetable.

Compliance and enforcement framework for Corporation Tax software

While respondents generally supported the need for software standards and proportionate measures to address non-compliance, they emphasised the importance of clear governance, transparent processes, effective communication and safeguards to protect taxpayers from unintended consequences of non-compliant software. 

  • They recognised the potential benefits of an approved software list, but raised concerns about the effect it would have on market competition, particularly for smaller providers and businesses using bespoke software.
  • Most respondents opposed blocking submissions where this could prevent taxpayers from meeting their filing obligations because of software issues outside their control.
  • Views on monetary penalties were mixed, though respondents generally considered that penalties should be reserved for clear, deliberate or persistent non-compliance rather than genuine errors or differences in interpretation.

Recognising respondents’ concerns about the potential impact of enforcement measures on taxpayers, agents and software providers, and the need for appropriate safeguards and flexibility within the prescribed computation requirements, the government:

  • Does not intend to take immediate action to introduce enforcement measures.
  • Will revisit the position alongside HMRC’s broader ongoing work on software standards.

Mandatory online filing of amended returns

  • Respondents broadly supported the mandatory online filing of amended company tax returns but stressed the need for retaining appropriate exceptions and alternative filing routes where online submission may not be suitable.
  • Respondents also referred to HMRC systems limitations, including file size restrictions, limits on the number of amendments, challenges in processing complex periods of account and wider IT issues that could prevent online filing in practice.

The government welcomes respondents’ support for making online filing the default method for submitting amendments to company tax returns whilst recognising the concerns raised about particular cases and technical constraints.

  •  It will proceed with implementing mandatory online filing for amended returns, with targeted exceptions where necessary.
    • The exceptions will be set out before the start date of April 2028, this having been delayed to allow time to provide the necessary clear and detailed guidance.
    • The guidance will also explain how the requirement applies to historic returns, long periods of accounts and returns originally submitted using legacy software.

The government recognises that many of the responses to the consultation extend beyond prescribed computations and the digital filing of amended returns, raising wider questions about the future administration of Corporation Tax. As such, alongside this work, it is seeking views through the Call for Evidence on Modernising the Administration of Corporation Tax.

Useful guides on this topic

Company tax rates and allowances
What is the rate of Corporation Tax? How does marginal relief work? Which companies pay the main rate of Corporation Tax? Which companies pay the small profits rate of Corporation Tax? How do I calculate Corporation Tax? 

Calculating Corporation Tax & Checklist
How do you calculate Corporation Tax? What is the small profits rate? How do you calculate Marginal Tax relief? How do you adjust for Associated Companies? What is meant by Control? What are Augmented profits?

Company Compliance checklist: Returns, filing & payments
A compliance basics end-of-the-year (and tax year) checklist for subscribers.

External link

Consultation response: Modernising and standardising company tax returns