- Last Updated: 13 May 2021
What was the difference between the facts and circumstances of the recent IR35 decisions on radio and TV hosts, Kay Adams, Lorraine Kelly, Christa Ackroyd and Eamonn Holmes?
All three have had their business arrangements tested before First Tier Tribunal (FTT) as follows:
- In Atholl House Productions Limited v HMRC [2019] TC07088, the FTT found that TV presenter Kay Adams was not subject to IR35. She was an independent provider of services carrying on a profession on her own account. The decision was upheld by the Upper Tribunal(UT). HMRC appealed on the basis that the FTT had erred in law when making the decision. The UT found that the FTT had erred in law but still came to the same conclusion, that Kaye Adams was carrying on a business in her own right, which was enough to displace the assumption of employment.
- In Albatel Limited v HMRC [2019] TC07045, the FTT allowed appeals against assessments of £1.2m on Lorraine Kelly’s personal service company. IR35 did not apply, ITV did not employ her, it was buying her brand.
- In Christa Ackroyd Media Limited v HMRC [2018] TC06334, the FTT held that a BBC television presenter was caught by the IR35 regulations. The decision has been upheld by the Upper Tribunal. The appeal related solely to the question of control and the UT held that there was sufficient control over Ms Ackroyd by the BBC for IR35 to apply.
- In Red, White and Green Limited v HMRC [2020] TC7603, the First Tier Tribunal (FTT) held that Eamonn Holmes' contract with ITV to present Good Morning was caught by IR35. There was mutuality of obligation and ITV had overall control.
Each case turns on its own facts, decisions made by the FTT do not set a judicial precedent however they can be very useful to follow. UT decisions do bind the FTT, so the cases that have been upheld by the UT have further weight.
Comparison of key features of each case
Who | Kay Adams | Lorraine Kelly | Christa Ackroyd | Eamonn Holmes |
Personal Service Company | Atholl House Productions Limited |
Albatel Ltd | Christa Ackroyd Media Limited | Red, White and Green limited |
End client | BBC | ITV | BBC | ITV |
Main programme | The Kay Adams Programme | Lorraine and Daybreak | Look North | Good Morning |
Also famous for role in: | Loose Women | TV-am, GMTV, ITV Breakfast | Calendar | ITV's This Morning, Sunrise (Sky News) |
Within IR35 | No | No | Yes - upheld by Upper Tribunal | Yes |
A brand in their own right | Not discussed | Yes | Not discussed | Not discussed |
Worked mainly for End-Client | No | Yes | Yes | No |
Length of End -Client contract | 1 Year | 2.5 years | 7 years | 1 Year |
Salient features of relationship with End-Client |
Wrote own scripts BBC did not have to consent to non-BBC engagements |
Little or no control by end client Wrote own scripts Considered a theatrical artist |
The BBC had sufficient control: Had first call on Ms Ackroyd’s time. She attended BBC training sessions Could be told by the BBC who to interview. Had to obtain the BBC's consent to non-BBC engagements |
ITV had control: Mr Holmes could not undertake work that conflicted with ITV Fixed fee paid for each show ITV could provide a substitute if needed, but Mr Holmes could not ITV provided travel and clothing ITV had full discretion and control as to editorial content |
Clothing allowance paid by End-Client | no | No | Yes | Yes |
Other points | Appeal dismissed by UT |
Appeal dismissed by UT |
Would you like to unlock the whole site?
Recommendations: read what subscribers have to say about this webservice.
Click here to SUBSCRIBE & join us. We have a fully transparent price list. Alternatively, Register for FREE news.
Enjoying the Practical Tax content on www.rossmartin.co.uk?
Sign up now to receive a unique FREE Tax Planning Tips and Advice Guide & our FREE Newsletter.